hotelhuddle
hotelhuddle Wherever you're going.
Get Started

Hotels in Shelter Island, New York

3 hotels found. Find your hotel and negotiate the best price.

Dering Harbor Inn
13 Winthrop Road
Shelter Island, New York 11965
View Details
Ram's Head Inn
118 South Ram Island Drive
Shelter Island, New York 11965
+1-631-749-0811
View Details
The Pridwin Hotel
81 SHORE ROAD
Shelter Island, New York
★★★
View Details